Not RatedGenComplete

Confidence (I Am)

Warnings
Creator chose not to add warnings
Fandom
Peter Pan & Related Fandoms
Main relationship
Peter Pan & Tinker Bell (Peter Pan)
Other relationships
Peter Pan & Shadow (Peter Pan) James Hook & Smee Can't decide if I ship this version of Hook & Smee or not
Main characters
Peter Pan (Peter Pan) Tinker Bell (Peter Pan)
Other characters
Shadow (Peter Pan) Pirates (Peter Pan) James Hook Smee (Peter Pan)
Other tags
Forests Neverland (Peter Pan) Dialogue Light Anxiety Self-Doubt Doubt Confidence Self Confidence Introspection Rivers waterfalls cliffs Peter is a magical chosen warrior child who spent his first years in the human world before being kidnapped by a bunch of pirates who want to raise him as their weapon but then he met Tink and escaped but he's still the unwilling chosen one so still imprisoned by Destiny but more free now at least also Shadow's nice but likes causing trouble so does Tink Overtagging overtagging is FUN My First Ever Peter Pan Fanfic So Smee is half fairy and sort of a good guy but he likes Hook so is on his crew Hook has just accepted the fact that this weird preachy halfling follows him around now
Language
English
Originally published
on AO3 · updated 21 May 2025
Stats
1,002 words3 chapters 14 sparks0 comments0 bookmarks10 readsUpdated 21 May 2025
Summary

Capture is better than death, freedom is better still. But surrender is so much easier than belief.

A Peter Pan origin story.

Notes

Peter is 10 in this.


Might add more to this story someday, idk

Chapter 2: Mistake Or Triumph

Captain Hook has a different last name until he actually loses his hand.

The head of Captain James Hatchet is in his hands as he leans on his desk. The pirates in front of him are cowering, most of them at least, even as he speaks oh-so-calmly. "What do you mean, 'he flew away'?"

 

"Just like a birdie, Cap'n.' One brave or perhaps stupid crewman tells him. The man chuckles. "It was quite cool, actually..."

 

"Quite cool, was it?" James asks darkly, lifting his head to glare at the men gathered in front of him. "I'm so glad you're enjoying yourself, but, need I remind you–" He scowls, slamming his hands hard on his desk as he stands to tower over them "–THIS MAKES IT HARDER TO CAPTURE HIM, YOU MORON!"

 

The pirates flee the Captain's cabin, chased by threats and orders to capture the boy. All except one, a particularly fat pirate in a silly red hat, with small spectacles in front of his kind eyes. He simply tuts, and begins to tidy up the various odds and ends the other knocked off or threw in his rage.

 

"Honestly, what did you expect from the boy, Captain?" He asks, frowning at a crack in a snowglobe. By the time he sets the orb down, the crack is gone. "He's the Neverchild, him having unusual powers is a given."

 

"Shut up, Smee." James groans, slumping into his chair, head back in his hands.

 

"Shutting up, Captain." Smee says cheerfully, having now moved on to dusting. After a moment, he continues. "I told you to be nicer to him, how many times did I warn you?"

 

"Too many, you overgrown fairy!" James snaps. "He is– was a prisoner, a weapon, not a houseguest!"

 

"He's a child." Smee rebukes. "A useful child. If you had just made him like you, maybe he wouldn't have run off."

 

"I'm not having this argument again." James says flatly, unwilling to continue a discussion they'd had too many times over the years. "Maybe you're right, Smee, but what's done is done. It's too late to change that. Now we need to get the brat back before the fairies get around to training him."

 

"We should have some time, then, as I imagine they'll want to get him fed and healed up a bit first." Smee says pointedly, hands on his hips. Behind him, the duster keeps on with its task.

 

"Shut up, Smee."

 

"Shutting up, Captain." Smee hums in thought "Speaking of feeding, when was the last time you ate? And have you slept at all since the boy escaped? You need to take care of yourself, Captain–"

 

James sighs, giving in to the other's mothering, letting the trivialities of food and tea and endless chattering distract him. But by the time Smee forces him to bed, he finds his mind spiralling with panic; the boy is gone, the fairies have Neverland's greatest weapon, and the pirates are unlikely to come out of this on top unless they get him back. By tracking him down and bringing him to Neverland in the first place, James has either made the biggest mistake of his life, or put into motion his and his crew's most glorious triumph.

 

Only time will tell.

14 carried over from the original posting

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Be the first to send some love!

Log in or join free to leave a comment. Guests can still send sparks!